(Senate - March 13, 2008)

Text available as:

Formatting necessary for an accurate reading of this text may be shown by tags (e.g., <DELETED> or <BOLD>) or may be missing from this TXT display. For complete and accurate display of this text, see the PDF.

[Pages S2035-S2036]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office []

                       SENATOR HOWARD METZENBAUM

  Mr. KENNEDY. Mr. President, all of us are deeply saddened with the 
loss of an extraordinary Senator and a great human being: Howard 
Metzenbaum. We extend our condolences to Shirley and to the members of 
the Metzenbaum family.
  He truly was the conscience of the Senate for so many years. This is 
an institution made up of 100 individuals, and all of us wonder whether 
any of us can make much of a difference in a group of 100. But history 
will show that Howard Metzenbaum made an extraordinary difference in 
this institution and for the working men and women of this country whom 
he championed.
  He was an unabashed champion for those who were left out and left 
behind. So often their interests and their well-being are forgotten, 
but they never were when Howard Metzenbaum served in this institution.
  Reference has been made to one of the great battles, among the many 
he fought, and that was on this issue of the deregulation of natural 
gas. Howard and Jim Abourezk and a few of us were interested in that 
issue. We were following the leadership of Howard Metzenbaum. He 
absolutely infuriated every Member of this body as he kept us here day 
and night, day and night, rollcall after rollcall, but he would not 
give up, and he would not give in.
  All of the Members were in an uproar, until finally a solution was 
reached and the Senate went in adjournment. As Senator Metzenbaum 
walked out on the Senate steps, Senator after Senator came up and 
congratulated him. They all were expressing a viewpoint that was 
unsaid, but they were basically saying beneath their breath that they 
hoped they could be the champion for their interests as Howard 
Metzenbaum was a champion for the interests of working men and women in 
this country.
  Howard could scold, he could hassle, he could provoke, he could 
cajole, but he also could smile and he could joke. He had a warm heart 
and a brilliant mind. He was a Senator's Senator. He will be greatly 
missed, but he will be greatly remembered as well for his service to 
this institution, which he loved, and for the people of Ohio, whom he 
served so nobly.
  Mr. COCHRAN. Mr. President, I was deeply saddened by the news of the 
death of our former colleague and friend, Howard Metzenbaum.
  The Senator from Ohio was one of the most conscientious, hardest 
working, and influential Senators I have had the privilege to observe 
since I came to the Senate in 1979.
  We were friends even though we would disagree on some subjects and be 
on the opposite sides of amendments he would offer on appropriations 
bills I was supporting. He was a fierce debater and would often become 
agitated and raise his voice level for effect. But, he always impressed 
me as sincere, honest, and relentless.
  The Senate and the United States were well served by Howard 
  Mr. HATCH. Mr. President, I rise to speak today regarding the passing 
of former Senator Howard Metzenbaum, who passed away last night at his 
home in Fort Lauderdale, FL. I think I speak for many of my colleagues 
when I say that our Nation has lost a principled leader and that 
Senator Metzenbaum will be missed.
  Senator Metzenbaum was born in Cleveland, OH in 1917 and spent much 
of his life serving the people of that great State. He graduated from 
Ohio State University in 1939 and received a law degree from that same 
institution in 1941. The early days of his legal practice were devoted 
to representing labor unions in Ohio.
  In 1943, he began an 8-year period of service in the Ohio State 
Legislature, serving 4 years in the Ohio House of Representatives and 4 
more in the Ohio Senate. He soon became a prominent figure in Ohio 
  After his time in the Ohio Legislature, he continued his legal 
practice and also embarked on a very successful career in real estate 
development, becoming a self-made millionaire through a series of very 
successful investments. However, he did not stay out of public service 
for long.
  In 1974, Senator Metzenbaum was appointed by Ohio Governor Jack 
Gilligan to fill the vacancy in the U.S. Senate left by Senator William 
B. Saxbe who had departed to serve as U.S. Attorney General. After 
losing a tough primary election to future Senator John Glenn later that 
year, Howard was elected to Ohio's other Senate seat in 1976, the same 
year I came to the Senate. He served three Senate terms before retiring 
in 1995.
  I had the privilege of serving with Howard for his entire career in 
the Senate. It always amazed me how dedicated Howard was and how he 
dutifully watched out for his constituents' interests. It seemed like 
he was always on the floor at the right time and ready to stop any 
amendment that he thought might go against the principled views he 
  For many years, Howard's Senate office was across the hall from my 
office on the first floor of the Russell Senate Office Building. 
Frequently, when there was a vote, Howard and I would enter the hallway 
at the same time and he would immediately make a statement about the 
loud tie I was wearing. He never failed to notice the unique collection 
of ties I wore. However, over the years, I noticed his selection of tie 
choices began to grow louder and louder as well until eventually, we 
used to see who could wear the most outlandish ties to work each day. 
We sure did wear some ugly ties trying to outdo each other. We really 
developed quite a fondness for each other during those years.
  As you might expect, Howard and I often found ourselves butting heads 
on many issues. He certainly had a tendency, at times, to frustrate 
some of our colleagues. However, we all admired him for his courage and 
  Howard was a tough politician. As we came to the close of each of our 
Senate work periods right before a recess began, you could always find 
Howard sitting at his desk on the Senate floor objecting to every piece 
of legislation that he did not agree with. He spent hour upon hour 
standing up for the people of Ohio.
  Howard's enthusiasm in protecting the interests of Ohioans was 
probably the only thing that exceeded his zeal in guarding against 
legislation that he viewed as helping large corporations. I recall with 
some amusement an incident surrounding an amendment I was trying to add 
to a tax bill on the Senate floor that would have lowered excise taxes 
for certain companies that supplied materials to mining companies. This 
amendment had been cleared by the managers of the bill, who were the 
leaders of the Finance Committee. It appeared that acceptance of the 
amendment was a done deal.
  That is, until Senator Metzenbaum found out that a potentially pro-
corporation amendment was about to be accepted.
  Howard began objecting to the unanimous consent request to include 
this amendment in the bill. During a call of the quorum, I went over to 
chat with him. I informed him that of the roughly two or three dozen 
mining supply companies that would be helped by this amendment, three 
were located in Ohio. I could see in his eyes the difficult nature of 
his dilemma--on the one hand he did not want to spend money on helping 
corporations and on the other hand, he always wanted to help his 
beloved Ohioans.
  In the end, Howard made what he thought was the best decision for his 
constituents and agreed to let the amendment go, but not before he had 
a chance to weigh in his mind the importance of his decision. I 
remember thinking at the time that I had probably witnessed one of the 
only times Howard ever changed his mind regarding a piece of 
  Mr. President, I want to extend my deepest sympathies to the 
Metzenbaum family. As I said, Howard and I didn't often find ourselves 
on the same side of matters before the Senate, but I can say, without 
reservation, that he was a dedicated public servant, a man I have 
always admired and a dear friend.

[[Page S2036]]

  Mr. BYRD. Mr. President, I was saddened to learn that my good friend 
and former colleague, Senator Howard Metzenbaum, has passed away.
  He was a man of courage, conviction, commitment, and toughness. He 
was a labor lawyer and union lobbyist, who grew up in poverty, and went 
on to become a champion of the rights of American workers. He was a 
self-made millionaire who became a dedicated adversary of big business.
  I was honored to work with him in the Senate for 18 years. He was an 
unabashed liberal who brought such an intensity to any issue he was 
promoting, that it was a pleasure simply to watch him as he worked. It 
was the high level of energy and emotion that he brought to the issues 
about which he felt most deeply that prompted me to remark at one 
point, ``Some men have succeeded in politics through diplomacy and 
compromise, [but] Howard Metzenbaum's forte has been his passion.''
  And he was passionate about liberal causes. During his career in the 
Senate, he wrote legislation on nutrition-labeling, funding for 
``orphan drugs'' for rare diseases, airline safety, and penalties for 
violations of child-labor laws.
  It was a delight to work with him in the incredibly productive 100th 
Congress--and he was one of the reasons that that particular Congress 
was so productive. Some of the legislation that Senator Metzenbaum 
sponsored during that Congress included plant-closing notification and 
a massive worker-retaining program.
  Mr. President, Senator Metzenbaum's support for liberal causes earned 
him a variety of labels and descriptions. While the Wall Street Journal 
branded him ``Senator No'' for his determination and ability to block 
legislation that favored special interests, the Dayton Daily News 
called him ``Senator Can Do'' for his legislative accomplishments.
  The Cleveland Plain Dealer described him as the ``watch dog for 
American consumers.'' The Gannet News service called him the 
``millionaire friend of the little guy.'' The Congressional Quarterly 
depicted him as the ``Democratic Gatekeeper.'' In his weekly newspaper 
column, Senator Paul Simon called him ``the tiger of the Senate.'' The 
head of Handgun Control, Sara Brady, labeled him a ``hero'' for his 
leadership in fighting for the Brady bill and other gun-control 
measures. I was privileged to be able to call Senator Metzenbaum 
``friend'' and ``colleague.''
  American workers and American consumers, as well as members of the 
Senate, the State of Ohio, and the citizens of our beloved country are 
all so much better off because he served in this chamber for nearly two 
  Mr. President, during one of his fights against special interests, 
the Washington Post editorialized, ``Thank God for Metzenbaum.'' I 
loved that remark because I, too, wish to ``thank God for [Senator] 
  Mr. HARKIN, Mr. President, I was saddened to learn of the death, last 
night, of former Senator Howard Metzenbaum of Ohio. But my grief is 
leavened by wonderful memories of this extraordinary person and all 
that he accomplished during his nearly two decades in this body.
  There are several essential, bedrock things you quickly learned about 
Howard Metzenbaum. He was proud, unreconstructed, irrepressible 
liberal. He was a fighter who never gave in or gave up. And he was 
utterly intolerant of injustice or discrimination toward any human 
  In many ways, he was a classic child of the Great Depression, raised 
amidst poverty and anti-Semitic prejudice, and reared on the speeches 
of his hero, Franklin D. Roosevelt.
  Howard was a self-made man who said that he was ``born knowing how to 
make money.'' And he did, indeed, make a fortune in the business world. 
But, for Howard, money was not an end in itself. It gave him the 
freedom to devote himself to public service and to the causes that he 
believed in so passionately.
  Howard and I shared a common interest in combating child labor and 
child slavery around the world. I especially admired his work as a 
founding member of the RUGMARK Foundation, a non-profit organization 
dedicated to fighting child labor in the hand-made carpet industry, 
especially in countries like India and Pakistan.
  He poured all his energy and prestige as a U.S. Senator into getting 
RUGMARK started, and building it into the successful humanitarian 
organization that it is today. And on many occasions, he joined with 
other anti-child-labor activists in picketing outside of rug stores 
that persisted in selling products made with abusive child labor.
  Of course, Howard's fight for social and economic justice extended 
into many other arenas.
  For many years, he worked as a lawyer for labor unions, and he always 
believed passionately in unions as instruments for lifting people up 
and fighting for justice. It was Senator Metzenbaum who passed the law 
requiring 60-day notice before a plant could be closed.
  And I dare say that the Senate has never had a more outspoken 
advocate for the American consumer. In fact, after he retired from the 
Senate, Howard served as chairman of the Consumer Federation of 
America. He fought for access to affordable prescription drugs. And, 
with good reason, he was especially proud of the law he passed 
requiring nutrition labels on all processed food products.
  Food labels--listing calories, fat, salt, and cholesterol content--
have changed the way Americans shop, and they have given us an 
important tool for taking charge of our own health. Howard's work on 
food product labels was the inspiration for my own bill, which would 
require chain restaurants to provide similar information on the 
nutritional content of regular menu items.
  Mr. President, those of us who were privileged to serve in the Senate 
with Howard Metzenbaum will never forget his sharp wit and equally 
sharp tongue. He didn't come to the Senate to be Mr. Popularity; he 
came here to get things done and to change the world for the better.
  And that's exactly what Senator Metzenbaum did during his 19 years in 
this body. He was a tireless, outspoken voice for working families and 
union members, for the poor, and for anyone who is oppressed, 
exploited, or discriminated against.
  Mr. President, there was one other great passion in Howard 
Metzenbaum's life, and that was his love for Shirley, his wife and 
partner for more than five decades. My thoughts and prayers, today, are 
with Shirley.
  She is saying goodbye to her beloved husband. We are saying goodbye 
to one of the true giants of the Senate in the late 20th century.