[Pages H3481-H3487]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]

CALLING ON CHINA TO RELEASE LI SHAOMIN AND ALL OTHER AMERICAN SCHOLARS
OF CHINESE ANCESTRY BEING HELD IN DETENTION

Mr. SMITH of New Jersey. Madam Speaker, I move to suspend the rules
and agree to the resolution (H. Res. 160) calling on the Government of
the People's Republic of China to immediately and unconditionally
release Li Shaomin and all other American scholars of Chinese ancestry
being held in detention, calling on the President of the United States
to continue working on behalf of Li Shaomin and the other detained
scholars for their release, and for other purposes, as amended.
The Clerk read as follows:

[[Page H3482]]

H. Res. 160

Whereas in recent months the Government of the People's
Republic of China has arrested and detained several scholars
and intellectuals of Chinese ancestry with ties to the United
States, including at least 2 United States citizens and 3
permanent residents of the United States;
Whereas according to the Department of State's 2000 Country
Reports on Human Rights Practices in China, and international
human rights organizations, the Government of the People's
Republic of China ``has continued to commit widespread and
well-documented human rights abuses, in violation of
internationally accepted norms'';
Whereas the harassment, arbitrary arrest, detention, and
filing of criminal charges against scholars and intellectuals
has created a chilling effect on the freedom of expression,
in contravention of internationally accepted norms, including
the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights,
which the People's Republic of China signed in October 1998;
Whereas the Government of the People's Republic of China
frequently uses torture and other human rights violations to
produce coerced ``confessions'' from detainees;
Whereas the Department of State's 2000 Country Reports on
Human Rights Practices in China has extensively documented
that human rights abuses in the People's Republic of China
``included instances of extrajudicial killings, the use of
torture, forced confessions, arbitrary arrest and detention,
the mistreatment of prisoners, lengthy incommunicado
detention, and denial of due process'', and also found that
``[p]olice and prosecutorial officials often ignore the due
process provisions of the law and of the Constitution . . .
[f]or example, police and prosecutors can subject prisoners
to severe psychological pressure to confess, and coerced
confessions frequently are introduced as evidence'';
Whereas the Government of the People's Republic of China
has reported that some of the scholar detainees have
``confessed'' to their ``crimes'' of ``spying'', but it has
yet to produce any evidence of spying, and has refused to
permit the detainees to confer with their families or
lawyers;
Whereas the Department of State's 2000 Country Reports on
Human Rights Practices in China also found that ``police
continue to hold individuals without granting access to
family or a lawyer, and trials continue to be conducted in
secret'';
Whereas Dr. Li Shaomin is a United States citizen and
scholar who has been detained by the Government of the
People's Republic of China for more than 100 days, and was
formally charged with spying for Taiwan on May 15, 2001;
Whereas Dr. Li Shaomin has been deprived of his basic human
rights by arbitrary arrest and detention, and has not been
allowed to contact his wife and child (both United States
citizens), or his lawyer;
Whereas Dr. Gao Zhan is a permanent resident of the United
States and scholar who has been detained by the Government of
the People's Republic of China for more than 114 days, and
was formally charged with ``accepting money from a foreign
intelligence agency'' on April 4, 2001;
Whereas Dr. Gao Zhan has been deprived of her basic human
rights by arbitrary arrest and detention, and has not been
allowed to contact her husband and child (both United States
citizens), her lawyer, or Department of State consular
personnel in China;
Whereas Wu Jianmin is a United States citizen and author
who has been detained by the Government of the People's
Republic of China, has been deprived of his basic human
rights by arbitrary arrest and detention, has been denied
access to lawyers and family members, and has yet to be
formally charged with any crimes;
Whereas Qin Guangguang is a permanent resident of the
United States and researcher who has been detained by the
Government of the People's Republic of China on suspicions of
``leaking state secrets'', has been deprived of his basic
human rights by arbitrary arrest and detention, has been
denied access to lawyers and family members, and has yet to
be formally charged with any crimes;
Whereas Teng Chunyan is a permanent resident of the United
States, Falun Gong practitioner, and researcher who has been
sentenced to three years in prison for spying by the
Government of the People's Republic of China, apparently for
conducting research which documented violations of the human
rights of Falun Gong adherents in China, has been deprived of
her basic human rights by being placed on trial in secret,
and her appeal to the Beijing Higher People's Court was
denied on May 11, 2001;
Whereas Liu Yaping is a permanent resident of the United
States and a businessman who was arrested and detained in
Inner Mongolia in March 2001 by the Government of the
People's Republic of China, has been deprived of his basic
human rights by being denied any access to family members, by
being denied regular access to lawyers, is reported to be
suffering from severe health problems, and has yet to be
formally charged with any crimes;
Whereas because there is documented evidence that the
Government of the People's Republic of China uses torture to
coerce confessions from suspects, and because the Government
has thus far presented no evidence to support its claims that
the detained scholars and intellectuals are spies, and
because spying is vaguely defined under Chinese law, there is
reason to believe that the ``confessions'' of Dr. Li Shaomin
and Dr. Gao Zhan may have been coerced; and
Whereas the arbitrary imprisonment of United States
citizens and residents by the Government of the People's
Republic of China, and the continuing violations of their
fundamental human rights, demands an immediate and forceful
response by Congress and the President of the United States:
Now, therefore, be it
Resolved, That--
(1) the House of Representatives--
(A) condemns and deplores the continued detention of Li
Shaomin, Gao Zhan, Wu Jianmin, Qin Guangguang, Teng Chunyan,
and other scholars detained on false charges by the
Government of the People's Republic of China, and calls for
their immediate and unconditional release;
(B) condemns and deplores the lack of due process afforded
to these detainees, and the probable coercion of confessions
from some of them;
(C) condemns and deplores the ongoing and systematic
pattern of human rights violations by the Government of the
People's Republic of China, of which the unjust detentions of
Li Shaomin, Gao Zhan, Wu Jianmin, Qin Guangguang, and Teng
Chunyan, are only important examples;
(D) strongly urges the Government of the People's Republic
of China to consider carefully the implications to the
broader United States-Chinese relationship of detaining and
coercing confessions from United States citizens and
permanent residents on unsubstantiated spying charges or
suspicions;
(E) urges the Government of the People's Republic of China
to consider releasing Liu Yaping on medical parole, as
provided for under Chinese law; and
(F) believes that human rights violations inflicted on
United States citizens and residents by the Government of the
People's Republic of China will reduce opportunities for
United States-Chinese cooperation on a wide range of issues;
and
(2) it is the sense of the House of Representatives that
the President--
(A) should make the immediate release of Li Shaomin, Gao
Zhan, Wu Jianmin, Qin Guangguang, and Teng Chunyan a top
priority of United States foreign policy with the Government
of the People's Republic of China;
(B) should continue to make every effort to assist Li
Shaomin, Gao Zhan, Wu Jianmin, Qin Guangguang, and Teng
Chunyan, and their families, while discussions of their
release are ongoing;
(C) should make it clear to the Government of the People's
Republic of China, that the detention of United States
citizens and residents, and the infliction of human rights
violations upon United States citizens and residents, is not
in the interests of the Government of the People's Republic
of China because it will reduce opportunities for United
States-Chinese cooperation on other matters; and
(D) should immediately send a special, high ranking
representative to the Government of the People's Republic of
China to reiterate the deep concern of the United States
regarding the continued imprisonment of Li Shaomin, Gao Zhan,
Wu Jianmin, Qin Guangguang, Teng Chunyan, and Liu Yaping, and
to discuss their legal status and immediate humanitarian
needs.

The SPEAKER pro tempore. Pursuant to the rule, the gentleman from New
Jersey (Mr. Smith) and the gentleman from California (Mr. Sherman) each
will control 20 minutes.
The Chair recognizes the gentleman from New Jersey (Mr. Smith).
Mr. SMITH of New Jersey. Madam Speaker, I yield myself such time as I
may consume.
Madam Speaker, in an emotional appeal before the House Committee on
International Relations last Tuesday, the wife of Dr. Li Shaomin and
the husband of Dr. Gao Zhan, two highly respected scholars held hostage
by the People's Republic of China, asked Congress and the President to
leave no stone unturned in securing the release of their loved ones.
Also at that hearing, Mike Jendrzejczyk of Human Rights Watch made a
number of incisive comments and said, ``The detentions of respected
China scholars have sent a shock wave through the international
academic community. Many researchers are increasingly worried about the
risks of working in China, and have taken extraordinary steps to speak
out.''
He noted on April 17, more than 400 leading scholars from 14
countries, as well as Taiwan and Hong Kong, all of them who work in the
field of China studies, sent a petition to President Jiang Zemin. The
authors of the letter noted that the International Covenant on Civil
and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social
and Cultural Rights, the latter, which was ratified last February,
makes it very clear that holding academics and scholars are precluded
by international law. Movever, China's intolerance to free expression
will likely

[[Page H3483]]

deter other academics from pursuing research in the People's Republic
of China. The respected human rights leader bottom-lines it and says,
``The detentions raise serious questions about the rule of law in China
and whether it exists.''
Indeed, Madam Speaker, at least six Chinese American scholars and
intellectuals are today being unjustly detained. They are being held
hostage by the PRC, an outrage that demands immediate relief. H. Res.
160, which I introduced on June 8 and now has approximately 40
cosponsors, calls for the immediate and unconditional release of these
scholars and academics.
These include: Dr. Li Shaomin, who is a United States citizen and
scholar who has been detained by the PRC for 120 days and counting. He
has been deprived of his basic human rights by arbitrary arrest,
detention and indictment, and has not been allowed to contact his wife
and child, both of whom are American citizens as well, nor has he been
in contact with his lawyer.
Dr. Gao Zhan is a permanent resident of the United States and is a
member of the faculty of American University. She has been detained by
the People's Republic of China for 134 days and counting.
Mr. Wu Jianmin is an American citizen and author who has been
detained by China and deprived of his basic human rights by arbitrary
arrest and detention.
Qin Guangguang is a permanent resident of the United States and a
researcher who has been detained by China on suspicions of leaking
state secrets. His human rights have been violated by arbitrary arrest
and detention.
Ms. Teng Chunyan is a permanent resident of the United States, a
researcher and a Falun Gong practitioner. She has been sentenced to 3
years in prison for spying by the PRC. The apparent reason for her
sentence is her research showing that the PRC is violating the human
rights of Falun Gong adherents in China. If that is true, Madam
Speaker, the U.S. State Department is guilty of that charge. This
country's Report on Human Rights Practice, which catalogs the myriad of
human rights abuses by China, also points out that at least 100 Falun
Gong were tortured to death last year as part of their crackdown.
Then there is Mr. Liu Yaping. He is a permanent resident of the
United States and a businessman. He was arrested in Inner Mongolia in
March 2001. He has been diagnosed with severe health problems while in
detention, including a brain aneurysm which may rupture. The reason for
his arbitrary arrest and detention are unclear. He has had no contact
with his family, and has not had regular access to his lawyers.
Madam Speaker, at a hearing of the Committee on International
Relations, noting that both she and her husband, Li Shaomin, are
American citizens, Liu Yingli testified, ``If China's Ministry of State
Security can get away with imprisoning my husband now, it may well
detain more academics in China in the future, regardless of their skin
color, or country of origin.''
Despite the fact that Dr. Li is not a political activist or
dissident, but is a teacher who worked for AT&T in New Jersey for 8
years, Liu Yingli said, ``This case is not just about the freedom of
one man, but about academic freedom.'' Again, Dr. Li has been held
hostage for 120 days.
Liu Yingli also testified, ``It has been nearly 4 months since Li
Shaomin's detention on February 25: 4 months of grief and pain, 4
months of worry and fear. But we are American citizens. We should not
have to live with such fears.''
She said, ``This painful experience has not spared our daughter, who
is only 9, and our parents, who are more than 70 years old. Our family
has spent sleepless nights and restless days waiting for news of
Shaomin. Our daughter, Diana, has asked repeatedly when Daddy will come
home.''

{time} 1530

Madam Speaker, when this unjust detention was brought to my attention
I expressed concern and dismay. But when I met with Liu and her
daughter--I knew more--much more had to be done. Diana, the 9-year-old
daughter of Dr. Li asked me to help her dad. She composed two letters
and drawings in crayon that really hit home with me. One that was for
me and one I was asked to give to President Bush. I would just like to
quote the one that I gave to the President on April 25. I hand
delivered it to him.
``Hi, Mr. President,
``My name is Diana Li. I am 9 years old. I have never written to a
President before in my life. Now I am writing because China has
captured my daddy, Shaomin Li. I need your help to rescue my daddy.
Would you please help me? I miss my daddy very much. I can imagine if
you were captured by China, your daughters would miss you very much,
too. And so would their mom.
``Please help me rescue my daddy. Thank you. Diana Li.''
Madam Speaker, let us hope that the crayon is mightier than the sword
and that Beijing will understand the extreme folly of their hostage-
taking and listen as well to the plea of a 9-year-old asking for her
father.
And, Madam Speaker, the cases of the other hostages are equally
compelling. At the hearing last Tuesday, we also heard from Donghua
Xue, the husband of Dr. Gao Zhan, who has been held hostage for 134
days. Mr. Xue, a senior systems analyst at EDS Corporation, told us how
on February 11 when he and his wife, a U.S. permanent resident and
research fellow at American University and their 5-year-old son Andrew,
an American citizen, were leaving China after a brief vacation, were
arrested and detained. To quote Mr. Xue.
``The three of us were separated by force, blindfolded and held in
three different places.''
Donghua was held for 26 days. His 5-year-old son, an American
citizen, was separately held for 26 days without any contact whatsoever
with his parents or family members. Even our embassy in Beijing was in
the dark about this littlest hostage who, I need to say again, is an
American citizen.
Madam Speaker, it was and is abundantly clear that Mr. Xue is
desperately worried about his wife's condition, and he told us at the
hearing that her attorneys in Beijing have made several attempts to
visit her and they have all been denied. The only reason we can think
of, he went on to say, is that she perhaps has been physically tortured
or at least has some obvious wounds that they do not want the outside
world to see. In a word he went on, ``My wife Gao Zhan is in a very
dangerous situation. I am calling on the American government to try
even harder to help.''
In his testimony, Madam Speaker, Mr. Xue also underscored the Chinese
government's rhetorical commitment to the rule of law. He said ``the
Chinese Ambassador to the U.S. emphasized several times in his letters
to the congressional Members and to U.S. officials that, quote, ``China
is a country ruled by laws.'' The spokesman from the Chinese foreign
minister has said that they, quote, ``strictly follow the legal
procedures to deal with the scholars' cases.''
``I certainly wish that these statements were true,'' he went on,
``but from my nightmare experience in China, the statements are far
from reality. To make a family disappear from the earth for almost a
month, to illegally detain my son Andrew,'' he testified, ``a U.S.
citizen for 26 days, without even notifying the U.S. embassy, to
separate a 5-year-old American child by force from his legal guardians
and his family, to emotionally and psychologically torture a 5-year-old
child for several weeks just for interrogations hostage. These actions
not only violate Chinese and international laws and U.S.-China
treaties, these actions are inhuman and they are barbaric. We can only
associate these actions with the terrorism organizations, not with a
country that purports to be ruled by laws.''
Mr. Xue also made an important comparison, Madam Speaker, with the
way in which his wife's case has been portrayed and that of our 24
detained servicemen and women from the EP-3E reconnaissance aircraft. I
quote him again:
``When our 24 crew members had been detained in China, they were
allowed to meet with U.S. officials. They were allowed to send messages
to their families. They lived in a hotel condition according to news
reports. They were finally released after 11 days of diplomatic
negotiations. We don't know where our scholars are. We don't know

[[Page H3484]]

anything about my wife's health condition. But one thing we are 100
percent sure of, they are not living in a hotel condition. Why do they
treat crew members and the scholars so differently? It is the Chinese
government who is discriminating against the Chinese people. I hope the
American government pays the same effort as they did for the crew
members to rescue these detained scholars.''
Madam Speaker, I urge the passage of this resolution. Hopefully, this
is the first step in raising everyone's consciousness concerning this
outrage of hostage-taking of these Chinese Americans.
Madam Speaker, I reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. SHERMAN. Madam Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may
consume.
I rise in strong support of H. Res. 160. I commend my good friend and
colleague, the gentleman from New Jersey (Mr. Smith), for introducing
this important resolution and for his quite eloquent advocacy of it. We
have so often heard the pleas of children hurt by governments, hurt by
violations of human rights; and I think that it will often be quoted,
``Let the crayon be mightier than the sword.'' I say to the gentleman
from New Jersey, that is a line that I think we should remember.
Madam Speaker, this resolution calls on the government of the
People's Republic of China to immediately and unconditionally release
American scholars of Chinese ancestry, including both United States
citizens and U.S. permanent residents, being held in detention.
Unfortunately, the recent arrest of these scholars is only the latest
example of the Chinese Government's willingness to invent false
accusations against perfectly innocent people, especially those
involved in the noble but dangerous effort to secure human rights for
the people of China.
To illustrate the cost in human terms of China's brutality, let us
look at one case, one of the several cases that our colleague from New
Jersey brought up, and that is the case of Dr. Gao Zhan. Gao Zhan is an
academic who specializes in researching women's issues. She and her
husband are permanent residents of the United States and their 5-year-
old son, Andrew, is an American by birth. Gao and her family traveled
to China to visit relatives. As they stood in line at the Beijing
airport waiting for their flight back to the United States, they were
seized by Chinese officials. Each family member was forced into a
separate car waiting outside the terminal and taken away.
Imagine the horror of a mother being suddenly separated from her
child by nameless Chinese officials. Imagine the fear experienced by
Gao's husband as he was blindfolded, driven for hours to an unknown
location, and subsequently interrogated about his wife's research.
Imagine being a 5-year-old boy torn away from your parents under such
circumstances. Gao's son was taken to a state-run institution. He was
held alone for 26 days, completely separated from his family. Let me
repeat, a 5-year-old boy held alone for 26 days without his mother,
without his father, or without even access to his grandparents, who
happen to live in China.
These actions violate international law and bilateral agreements
between the United States and China, not to mention basic human decency
in the way of treating people, particularly a 5-year-old child. Chinese
authorities finally allowed Gao's husband to retrieve his son and
return to the United States. Gao, however, has not fared so well. She
is still imprisoned in China on false charges. The Chinese Government
refuses to reveal the nature of the so-called evidence against Gao or
to give her a chance to publicly defend herself with adequate defense
counsel.
We know about the cases of Gao Zhan and the other five scholars that
are specifically mentioned in the resolution because they have
connections to the United States. They are residents or citizens of the
United States. But let us also remember that there are tens of
thousands of Chinese citizens who have no connection with America but
are dissidents struggling to lay the groundwork for a future democratic
China. These thousands are locked away for years in Chinese jails.
There is no embassy to ask about them, no newspapers to write about
them, and they are relegated to a most uncertain and most inhumane
fate. We must remember them. We must honor them and the democratic
cause for which they fight.
As a first step, it is absolutely imperative that the Bush
administration make the release of these six Chinese Americans a top
priority in our relationship with the People's Republic of China. We
can win the release of these Chinese Americans if we bring this issue
to the highest level. If President Bush personally asks President Jiang
to release these and other imprisoned scholars, I am confident that Gao
Zhan will see her husband and son again, and that Li Shaomin will soon
come home to his wife and his daughter.
It is important that we pass this resolution. It is also important
that we keep these human rights abuses in mind when we decide what
position to take as a country and as a Congress on the issue of whether
the Olympics should be held in Beijing in 2008. It is perhaps
unfortunate that the administration has announced that it is neutral
with regard to that bid for the Olympics. But the Olympics stands for
something. It stands, in part, for the humane treatment of all people.
I think this Congress ought to take up and bring up on this floor the
resolution urging that the Olympics not be held in Beijing while human
rights abuses continue.
In addition, it is important that we as Members of Congress keep
these human rights issues in mind as we vote on annual, quote, ``normal
trade relations,'' also known as most-favored-nation status when that
issue comes to this floor. But for now, I urge all my colleagues to
support H. Res. 160.
Madam Speaker, I reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. SMITH of New Jersey. Madam Speaker, I yield such time as he may
consume to the gentleman from Indiana (Mr. Pence).
Mr. PENCE. Madam Speaker, I thank the gentleman for yielding me this
time, and I thank my colleague from New Jersey for his outstanding
leadership on House Resolution 160, calling on the Government of the
People's Republic of China to immediately and unconditionally release
Dr. Li Shaomin and other American scholars of Chinese ancestry
currently being held in detention. I also would commend the gentleman
from California (Mr. Sherman) for his eloquent words today in support
of this important resolution.
Madam Speaker, the Good Book says that we are to stand with those in
prison as though we ourselves were prisoners. In this well of liberty,
this well where resides the dreams and hopes and ambitions of freedom-
loving people all over the world, today's resolution authored by the
gentleman from New Jersey (Mr. Smith) is an important statement. It is
important that this Congress call on the Government of the People's
Republic of China to immediately and unconditionally release Dr. Li
Shaomin and other American scholars of Chinese ancestry held in
detention and that we call today on the President of the United States
to continue immediately and urgently working on behalf of their
release.
The Government of the People's Republic of China, Madam Speaker, has
targeted, arrested, and detained several scholars and intellectuals of
Chinese ancestry with ties to the United States, including, as
astonishingly as it may seem, two United States citizens and three
permanent residents of the United States of America. According to the
Department of State's 2000 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices in
China and international human rights organizations, the Government of
the PRC has, quote, ``continued to commit widespread and well-
documented human rights abuses in violation of internationally accepted
norms. Targeting of intellectuals and scholars for harassment,
arbitrary arrest, detention and criminal charges has created a chilling
effect on the nascent freedom of expression which has begun to take
hold within the People's Republic of China.''
Dr. Li Shaomin is a United States citizen, Madam Speaker, and a
scholar who has been detained by the Government of the PRC for more
than 100 days. He was formally charged with spying for Taiwan on May
15, 2001. Dr. Li has been deprived of his basic human rights by
arbitrary arrest and detention and has not, as the gentleman from New
Jersey (Mr. Smith) stated with passion, even been allowed to contact
his wife and child or his attorney or been offered even the most

[[Page H3485]]

rudimentary due-process rights which, while not secured and vouchsafed
for the citizens of China, certainly ought to be respected for the
citizens of the United States of America within the geographic
boundaries of China.
Accordingly, this resolution, Madam Speaker, does in fact condemn and
deplore the continued detention of Dr. Li, of Dr. Gao Zhan and other
scholars detained on false charges by the Government of China, calls
for their immediate release, deplores the lack of due process and urges
the Government of the PRC to consider carefully the implications to its
broader relationship with the United States through this detainment and
coercion of American citizens and citizens of Chinese descent.

{time} 1545

We need look no further, Madam Speaker, than the cover of The
Washington Post today, which speaks about China's concern about U.S.
actions affecting our long-term relationship.
Madam Speaker, I would say it is time for China to begin to worry how
its actions against American citizens will affect the relationship of
this body to that government.
I close again with that challenge, that quote, from two millennia ago
that we ought to stand with those that are in prison, Madam Speaker, as
though we ourselves were prisoners. We in this Congress should stand
today strongly for House Resolution 160 and call on the government of
the People's Republic of China to make this small step toward liberty.
Mr. SHERMAN. Madam Speaker, I yield 6 minutes to the distinguished
gentleman from New Jersey (Mr. Holt).
Mr. HOLT. Madam Speaker, as representatives of the American people,
with this resolution we will today urge the People's Republic of China,
in the strongest possible terms, to release Li Shoamin, a naturalized
American citizen, and I might add a constituent of mine from New
Jersey, from my congressional district, from custody of the Beijing
State Security Bureau, where he has been detained since February of
this year.
Our actions today are also intended to call attention to the other
scholars of Chinese ancestry who are being illegally detained in China.
I have met personally on three occasions with Liu Yingli, Mr. Li
Shaomin's wife and their charming young daughter, Diana.
When one meets with them and talks with them and sees the pain and
uncertainty that they are experiencing over the detainment of their
husband and father, it is impossible not to realize how important this
legislation is.
I am pleased to join my colleague, the gentleman from New Jersey (Mr.
Smith), in presenting this legislation and urging its passage.
Li Shaomin received his Ph.D. in sociology from Princeton a decade
and a half ago. He is a respected and published scholar in demography,
has contributed greatly to research focused on strategic management and
marketing.
On February 25, Dr. Li, who over the years has traveled frequently to
Beijing and other parts of China, was traveling across the border to
visit a friend. Upon crossing, Dr. Li was detained by state security
officials who claimed he had been, well, we do not know. They now say
he was engaged in espionage.
The detention of Dr. Li is just another in a string of a half dozen
arrests by Chinese authorities of academics who have connections with
China. We have a responsibility to let the Chinese Government know that
the United States and the world are aware of these actions, are
watching closely, and find this sort of behavior unacceptable.
The charges brought against Dr. Li are vague and unsubstantiated. The
fact that Dr. Li is the son of a prominent Chinese dissident, Li
Honglin, who now resides in Hong Kong, I think is a significant point.
It raises extremely serious questions of political motivation for the
Chinese detainment of Dr. Li.
Since his detention, Dr. Li's detention, Chinese authorities have
refused to release any information or describe any so-called evidence
that has surfaced against Dr. Li. Disturbingly, the Chinese authorities
also failed to inform Dr. Li's wife directly about the detention until
May 17, when she was informed by the state security ministry via
telephone that her husband was arrested and charged with espionage.
U.S. consular officials have not been granted sufficient access to him,
and in addition without explanation from the Chinese authority, Liu
Yingli and Dr. Li's lawyer have been denied access to Dr. Li.
Of course, all of this raises questions about the rights of people in
China who do not have the U.S. embassy watching out for their
interests, how much worse it must be for them.
The People's Republic of China is a proud nation that is increasingly
taking its place on the world stage. All of us are aware of their
desire to have increased trading relationships with the West; to host
the Olympic games; to be on the modern stage of nations. If China wants
to be a member of the community of nations, actions like the detainment
of Dr. Li are unacceptable and, I would argue, counterproductive. It is
only appropriate that Congress make clear that Dr. Li and other U.S.
citizens who are being illegally detained must be released.
Violation of human rights, violation of standards, international
standards of law, are not behavior consistent with a modern nation that
wants to be part of the modern world of trade, of academic inquiry and
exchange, and international exchange.
I urge my colleagues in the strongest possible terms to pass this
legislation. We must do all we can to see that these Americans are
released as quickly as possible.
Mr. SMITH of New Jersey. Madam Speaker, I reserve the balance of my
time.
Mr. SHERMAN. Madam Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may
consume.
Madam Speaker, I urge my colleagues to vote yes on H. Res. 160 and to
keep these issues in mind as other issues involving the U.S.-China
relationship come before this House.
Mr. GILMAN. Madam Speaker, I want to thank Chairman Hyde and the
distinguished East Asia and Pacific Subcommittee Chairman, The
gentleman from Iowa, Congressman Leach, for swiftly moving H. Res. 160,
a resolution calling on the Government of the People's Republic of
China to immediately and unconditionally release certain American
citizens and residents from detention in China. I commend the gentleman
from New Jersey, Mr. Smith for drafting this important, timely
resolution.
I am very concerned that Chinese-American citizens and U.S. permanent
residents of Chinese ancestry are being illegally held by the
government of the People's Republic of China. There is no rule of law
in that country. In China a person is not innocent until proven guilty.
A person's guild or innocence is predetermined by the government, and,
as we all know, thousands of arrests and imprisonments are carried out
for political reasons.
Let's be perfectly clear about this. Government sponsored kidnapping
is terrorism. It is no less a crime than what is being committed by
terrorists against Americans currently being held in the Philippines.
Madam Speaker, a you will recall, the People's Republic of China has
done this before. One year it held activist Harry Wu. Another time it
held Wang Dan and Wei Jingsheng. Harry Wu was released to ensure the
First Lady Hillary Clinton would attend the UN 1995 Beijing Women's
Conference. Wang Dan and Wei Jingsheng were temporally released in 1993
as China was bidding to host the 2000 Olympics game. For years the
Chinese dictatorship have been holding and releasing, and then holding
and releasing Catholic clergy loyal to Pope John Paul II. Some of these
hostages are beaten to death, some are eventually released, some
permanently, some temporarily after they are leveraged on MFN, WTO,
Taiwan or some other significant issue.
So let us be clear. Our State Department is on notice that we want
our people back immediately and unconditionally. The President should
put on hold any consideration about his meeting with Chinese leaders
until this occurs.
The Chinese government and the bureaucrats in the State Department
who are still in place from the previous Administration must understand
that our people are not pawns for trade. First the Chinese government
must return our people and then we can talk about other things, such as
trade.
The cautions U.S. response that we have given to date, just will not
do. The taking of our citizens is an outrage and they should be
released now and unconditionally. Accordingly, I strongly support H.
Res. 160.
Mr. HUNTER. Madam Speaker, I would like to make a statement on behalf
of H. Res. 160, a bill that I have cosponsored which calls on the
Chinese government to immediately and unconditionally release from
prison Dr. Li Shaomin and all other American scholars of Chinese
ancestry.

[[Page H3486]]

As you know, in recent months we have seen the shocking arrest of
United States citizens and permanent residents by the People's Republic
of China (PRC). These prisoners represent some of the best and
brightest of the U.S. academic and business communities, and they have
been falsely and tragically charged with committing crimes of espionage
and violation of ``state secrets'' laws while traveling in China. In
most cases, these prisoners have been held for long periods of time
without formal charges filed against them, without the ability to meet
with their attorneys, and without communication with their families and
loved ones.
Although the Chinese government has said that many of these
individuals have confessed to their crimes, our own State Department's
Country Reports on Human Rights Abuses contains condemning data showing
the PRC routinely denies prisoners basic due process rights, and
regularly extracts confessions by coercion.
As we know, this behavior by the Chinese is nothing new. We remember
the brutal way that their government suppressed a movement toward free
speech in Tiananmen Square a decade ago, and we have seen no redeeming
conduct since that time that would lead us to believe that they intend
to change their ways. It was just several weeks ago that an American
military aircraft was shot down while flying in international waters,
and the service members aboard held hostage while the Chinese
government attempted to force an apology by the United States. To this
date, we still have been unable to retrieve our own aircraft from their
country.
This unending succession of events is being watched on the world
stage by nations that the PRC would do well to please in order to
secure their place in the world economy. However, China neither feels
contrite regarding their actions, nor do they exhibit acceptable
efforts to improve their lot with democratic countries. Unfortunately,
the United States consistently regards them for their provocative and
brutal actions by extending to them a privileged trade status ideally
afforded friendly and democratic nations.
Madam Speaker, this legislation's passage would send a strong signal
to the Chinese government that their actions are barbaric and
unacceptable. When confronted with situations that threaten American
citizens abroad, it is absolutely necessary to speak in a united front.
We should also refuse to award them with the riches gleaned from an
unbalanced trading relationship that comes at the expense of American
jobs and national security.
Mr. WOLF. Madam Speaker, I rise in support of H. Res. 160, which
condemns and deplores the continued detention of Li Shaomin, Gao Zhan,
Wu Jianmin, Tan Guangguang, Teng Chunyan, and other scholars detained
on false charges by the Government of the People's Republic of China,
and calls for their immediate and unconditional release. The resolution
condemns and deplores the lack of due process afforded to these
detainees, and the probable coercion of confessions from some of them.
Furthermore, it condemns and deplores the ongoing and systematic
pattern of human rights violations by the Government of the People's
Republic of China. Also, the resolution strongly urges the Government
of the People's Republic of China to consider the implications to the
broader United States-Chinese relationship of detaining and coercing
confessions from United States citizens and permanent residents on
unsubstantiated spying charges or suspicions. In addition, the measure
urges the Government of the People's Republic of China to consider
releasing Liu Yaping on humanitarian grounds.
In addition, the measure expresses the sense of the House that human
rights violations inflicted on United States citizens and residents by
the Government of the People's Republic of China will reduce
opportunities of United States-Chinese cooperation on a wide range of
issues.
I congratulate Representative Smith for his work in bringing this
resolution to the floor. This is an important statement by the people's
House today. It says to the Government of China, that the U.S. House of
Representatives cares about the human rights abuses committed by the
Government of China.
Just two months ago in March, I had the honor of leading a ceremony
in which my constituent, Dong Hau Xue, husband of the imprisoned
American University scholar named in this legislation, Dr. Gao Zhan,
became a U.S. citizen.
This ceremony was bittersweet. When he and his wife first applied for
permanent residency 1998, it had been their hope and prayer that they
would experience the joyous day of citizenship together, having both
completed the requirements of citizenship.
But this was not to be. Gao Zhan should have been standing alongside
her husband and their 5-year-old son Andrew. Instead, Gao Zhan was
languishing in a Chinese prison, thousands of miles away, separated
from her family and loved ones.
Today marks Gao Zhan's 134th day in captivity. Gao Zhan is an
academic researcher at the American University studying women's issues.
What kind of government imprisons academics who focus on women's
issues?
I know how grim conditions can be in Chinese prisons. I visited
Beijing Prison #1 in 1991 where some 40 Tiananmen Square demonstrators
were being held. When I was in Tibet, I talked with several individuals
who had been in Drapche Prison who told me of the horrible conditions.
It is an outrage that a country pressing to host the athletes of the
world during the 2008 Summer Olympic games continues to abuse the basic
human rights of citizens and visitors to their nation.
If the Chinese government ever hopes to have any credibility in the
world community, China must immediately release Gao Zhan, an innocent
women, wife and mother; U.S. citizens Dr. Li Shaomin and Mr. Wu
Jianmin; permanent U.S. residents Mr. Qin Guangguang, Mrs Teng Chunyan,
and Mr. Liu Yaping.
I urge a unanimous vote in support of H. Res. 160 and I implore the
government of the People's Republic of China to free Gao Zhan and the
other scholars and reunite them with their families.
Mr. DeLAY. Madam Speaker, I rise today because I am outraged.
Outraged that the People's Republic of China is holding American
scholars against their will. H. Res. 160, introduced by my colleague
Mr. Smith of New Jersey, takes an important step toward addressing the
human and civil rights abuses committed by the Communist Chinese
government. This Congress must not let human rights abuses by China or
any other nation go unchecked.
At the present time, Li Shaomin and other scholars are being held in
Chinese prisons for ``crimes against the State.'' These Americans may
be enduring torture and coercion, and may be forced into ``confessing''
to crimes they did not commit. But these are perhaps the least of the
indignities that these men and women must endures.
The imprisonment of Li Shaomin and other American scholars of Chinese
ancestry are just symptoms of the larger disease that is China's
blatant disregard for human life and human rights. It is clear from the
State Department's 2000 Country Report on Human Rights Practices in
China, that the Communist Chinese government commits, on a daily basis,
violations of the most essential and basic human rights.
Let our support for this resolution send a clear and compelling
signal that this Congress and our Nation will not stand silently by
while natural and universal human rights are curtailed in China or
anywhere else.
Mr. FALEOMAVAEGA. Madam Speaker, I rise in strong support of House
Resolution 160.
Madam Speaker, I am deeply disturbed by the Government of China's
recent arrests and detentions of American citizens and U.S. permanent
residents of Chinese ancestry.
Prosecutions of Americans by China's State Security Ministry and
agencies have been rare since the Korean War. With the recent outbreak
of detentions, however, it is troubling that China may now feel it
acceptable to target American subjects--as long as they have Chinese
blood.
In particular, I find it deplorable that those detained have been
held virtually incommunicado for months--denied any contact with
immediate family members and even their attorneys. Given the lack of
due process and the hidden, clandestine proceedings, it is no wonder
that China's charges of espionage and other serious violations against
the detainees are viewed as false, and any confessions produced as
resulting from torture.
In an effort to address these matters, Madam Speaker, I commend Mr.
Smith, Mr. Lantos and Ms. Ros-Lehtinen for introducing House Resolution
160. I am honored to be a co-sponsor of the measure.
In addition to calling upon the Chinese Government for the immediate
and unconditional release Dr. Li, Dr. Geo and other American scholars
of Chinese ancestry who have been detained, this important legislation
urges President Bush to appoint a special envoy and make the detainees'
release a top priority in U.S.-Sino relations.
I cannot agree more Madam Speaker, as American citizens and U.S.
permanent residents, when they go overseas, must be protected and not
be subject to arbitrary harassment and detention on unsubstantiated
charges, whether by China or any other nation.
I strongly urge adoption of the legislation by our colleagues.
Mr. SHERMAN. Madam Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time.
Mr. SMITH of New Jersey. Madam Speaker, we do have some additional
speakers; but regrettably, they are either en route from their home
districts or are in appropriations markups. So

[[Page H3487]]

at this point since they are not here, Madam Speaker, I yield back the
balance of our time.
The SPEAKER pro tempore (Mrs. Biggert). The question is on the motion
offered by the gentleman from New Jersey (Mr. Smith) that the House
suspend the rules and agree to the resolution, H. Res. 160, as amended.
The question was taken.
The SPEAKER pro tempore. In the opinion of the Chair, two-thirds of
those present have voted in the affirmative.
Mr. SMITH of New Jersey. Madam Speaker, on that I demand the yeas and
nays.
The yeas and nays were ordered.
The SPEAKER pro tempore. Pursuant to clause 8 of rule XX and the
Chair's prior announcement, further proceedings on this motion will be
postponed.

____________________